Blog Post
Blog Post

Don’t rush to regulate internet, support it

In Kenya, like elsewhere around the world, more people are texting and calling via Skype, WhatsApp, Facebook, Viber and other free messaging apps, collectively referred to as Over the Top (OTT) services.

The increased use of these services is fundamentally changing telcos’ revenue mix and disrupting broadcast media as online video streaming services gnaw into the market share of pay TV operators.

Although voice and SMS have, historically, been the key revenue drivers for telcos, their contribution to overall service revenues is decelerating.

By contrast, data has emerged as a key revenue driver — a trend attributed to the rising popularity of OTT messaging.

From 2015 to 2018, mobile data’s overall contribution to Safaricom’s service revenue almost doubled from nine percent to 16 percent as voice and SMS’s fell from 66 percent to 50 percent, its investor presentations show.

TARIFF

It is tempting for telcos to view OTTs as a threat to be countered rather than an opportunity to be tapped.

Their primary concern is that OTTs are undercutting voice and SMS revenue while not paying regulatory or maintenance fees for the physical infrastructure.

Regulatory and policy responses to this differ. In India, the telecoms regulator is leading consultations with industry stakeholders to assess the cost and benefits of regulating OTTs with revenue sharing models between them and telcos being proposed.

In Zambia, the government’s response has been more heavy-handed. It has introduced a $0.03 (Sh3) daily tariff on online phone calls with the Information minister saying 80 percent of Zambians use OTTs and this is to protect telcos.

Uganda’s Parliament imposed a $19 annual tax on social media usage while the Tanzania Communications Regulatory Authority has started licensing bloggers.

TAX

In view of the above, debate on regulating OTTs in Kenya is likely to gain momentum.

President Uhuru Kenyatta’s proposal to increase tax on internet data services from 10 percent to 15 percent could set the stage for a more aggressive policy stance towards them.

Legacy players in the telco and media space should fight the temptation to lobby for regulatory action against OTTs.

Regulators should also create an environment where telcos can collaborate with messaging apps and broadcasters with online video streaming services in win-win strategic partnerships.

The financial services sector offers critical lessons in this regard. In 2007, when mobile money emerged in Kenya, banks fought it and even unsuccessfully lobbied the central bank to intervene.

INNOVATION

Today, the most competitive banks are those collaborating with mobile money providers and capitalising on areas such as mobile microlending.

Regulate innovation without killing it. That is the key to attracting and retaining global internet firms, which not only make big-ticket investments but also help to stimulate skills, knowledge and technology transfer to local players.

The internet is doing to markets such as Kenya what railroads did to Western economies in the 19th century — opening up opportunities. Regulators should shun protectionist policies and promote free competition.

Recent Blog Posts
Aug
13
Failure to address the ‘people’ component of an infrastructure project, leads projects to fail: Four lessons for managing stakeholders

Infrastructure projects throw up a complex ecosystem of stakeholders that requires proactive management.  Understanding the political economy and the needs and expectations of stakeholders is key to realising Read more

Jun
23
Ethiopia: attempted coup unlikely to reverse reform direction

Ethiopia’s army chief of staff Seare Mekonen and the regional governor of Amhara state Ambachew Mekonnen were both assassinated on 22 June in two separate but reportedly related incidents which are being described as an attempted coup. According Read more

May
30
South Africa’s new cabinet

South African President Cyril Ramaphosa on 29 May announced a streamlined cabinet of 28 Ministers, down from 36 in the previous government. However, 34 Deputy Ministers were also retained, reflecting the difficulties of slimming a cabinet in a Read more

May
13
Five conclusions from the South African election result

South Africa’s electoral commission on 11 May announced the ruling African National Congress (ANC) as the winner of the 2019 elections with 57.5% of the vote, equating to 230 seats in the 400-seater parliament. This is the first time since the e Read more

May
09
Zambia: Struggling beneath the burden

The IMF completed its mission to Zambia last week and concluded that growth is expected to slow to 2.3% in 2019 (from 3.7% in 2018) while inflation is set to rise. Reserves are woefully low at less than 1.7 months import cover (as at end of March Read more

Apr
12
Out of the frying pan, into the fire

Following weeks of escalating protests in Khartoum, the Sudanese military has toppled President Omar al-Bashir in a coup that brings an end to his 30 years in power. But any celebrations that might have been triggered by Bashir’s overthrow ha Read more


^ Back to Top